Nurses Union Will Keep Fighting for Medicare for All

By Rose Ann DeMoro for the Nation –

Now that the Supreme Court has upheld the Affordable Care Act, former insurance company executive Wendell Potter's appeal to single payer advocates to "bury the hatchet," recently published in The Nation, is both misdirected and shortsighted.

Potter argues that insurance industry pirates will exploit left critiques of the ACA to subvert implementation of the law. He calls on proponents of more comprehensive reform to forgive and forget, embracing the massive concessions made by the Obama administration and its liberal allies.

But there are some gaping holes in this thinking.

First, the insurers hardly need to rely on the single-payer movement to sabotage elements of the law they don't like. They have office towers full of high-priced lawyers who are adept at identifying loopholes in the much-touted consumer protection provisions, like the bans on pre-existing condition exclusions or dropping coverage when patients get sick, or limiting how much money can be siphoned off for profits and paperwork.

Second, let's not have illusions about the history of the ACA.

Before he was elected, President Obama, an advocate of single-payer when he was in the Senate, called on progressives to push him. Instead, most of the liberals reduced themselves to cheerleading while all the pressure came from the right.

So when the healthcare bill was introduced, the President, with the active encouragement of groups like Health Care for America Now, blocked single payer from consideration. Persuading people through consent, rather than coercion, to accept inadequate solutions for societal needs has long been a key feature of the neoliberal agenda. It's one reason so many people vote against their own interests.

To get any hearing from Sen. Max Baucus, who was running the Senate side of the debate, nurses, doctors, and single-payer healthcare activists had to get arrested in a Senate Finance Committee hearing. On the House side, Democrats who proposed single payer amendments endured heavy-handed threats from then-White House chief of staff Rahm Emanuel. Meanwhile, then-Press Secretary Robert Gibbs publicly attacked the "professional left" who will only "be satisfied when we have Canadian healthcare and we've eliminated the Pentagon."

It should not come as a surprise that negotiating with your supporters before engaging political opposition, and lecturing, hectoring and seeking to silence healthcare activists who have worked for years for real reform, Obama and the Democrats ended up with a weaker bill. That bill lacked the public option HCAN and other liberals had claimed would be their bottom line, while HCAN and other liberals embraced the individual mandate – the brainchild of the right-wing Heritage Foundation – as high principle.

rest at http://www.healthcare-now.org/nurses-union-will-keep-fighting-for-medicare-for-all