Racism In The Tea Parties
In passing a resolution condemning the racist elements within the Tea Party this week, the NAACP set off a media firestorm over the merits of its charge against the right-wing movement. As the Atlantic's Ta-Nehisi Coates notes, critics bemoaned the resolution as a silly stunt that "heightened division" and implied that racist extremists define the membership of the Tea Party. Such a wholesale charge would certainly be exaggerated and inaccurate, but that was not the charge the NAACP made. "The resolution was amended during the debate to specifically ask the Tea Party itself to repudiate the racist elements and activities of the Tea Party." As NAACP President and CEO Ben Jealous said, "We're simply asking them to repudiate racist acts and bigotry in their ranks or accept responsibility." But instead of acknowledging and disassociating themselves from the more radical actions of their membership, Tea Party leaders have said that racist elements are non existent. In hurling accusations of racism back at the NAACP, Tea Party leaders have wielded a professed desire for colorblindness as a whitewashing tool. But Tea Party members are employing a defense that only perpetuates the racism they are desperately trying to refute.
YES, THERE IS RACISM: Galled by the NAACP's shot across the bow, Tea Party leaders and sympathizers immediately dismissed the charge of racism in the movement as unrepresentative or unfounded. Former Alaska governor Sarah Palin sounded off on Facebook this week, decrying the racism accusation as a "false" and "appalling" insult of which the "patriots of the tea party movement are truly undeserving." Conservative Bishop E.W. Jackson shrugged off the displays of racist tendencies, claiming "people will sometimes say things." He insisted that "the idea that the tea party movement is racist or that it has racist elements that need to be denounced is a nonsensical statement." At this point, the overwhelming evidence of such "radical elements" is enough to discredit any outright dismissal of the NAACP's claim. The North Iowa Tea Party recently launched a billboard that equates President Obama with flagrant racist Adolf Hitler. In April, Tea Party member and New York GOP gubernatorial hopeful Carl Paladino forwarded "racially degrading material" in emails, one of which was posted at the Neo-Nazi Stormfront website. Ironically, the clearest example of endorsed racism was offered by the Tea Party Express chairman and spokesperson Mark Williams. While contending that it's the NAACP that is "bigoted," Williams has made outright bigoted comments, referring to Allah as the "terrorists' monkey God," to a Jewish developer as a "Jewish Uncle Tom," and to Muslims as "semi-human, bipedal primates with no claim to be treated like humans." In responding to the NAACP's charge, he accused the group of being "professional race baiters" who "make more money than any slave trader ever."
THE PURPOSE: The passage of the resolution sparked a deep debate over the NAACP's intentions. Critics quickly decried the resolution as a blanket indictment of all Tea Party members as racist. Conservative African-American activist and GOP nominee for Congress in South Carolina Tim Scott viewed the resolution as "a grave mistake in stereotyping a diverse group of Americans." Republican National Committee Chairman Michael Steele saw the resolution as "destructive" and an effort to say "the Tea Party movement is racist." But as the Washington Post's E.J. Dionne Jr. pointed out, nothing the NAACP put forward supports that idea. "Its contention is that there are clearly racist strains in the Tea Party and that the movement's leaders and the politicians who profit from its activism should denounce them plainly and unequivocally," he said. Jealous clearly delineated the intention in Kansas City, calling on the Tea Party to "expel the bigots and racists in your ranks or take the responsibility for them and their actions." In his explanation to Dionne, Jealous said that "we have never called the Tea Party racist. We know there are black Tea Party members." The essential point of the resolution was not to erroneously paint Tea Party members as wholesale racists but rather to demand they disassociate with the radicals in their ranks.
HIDING BEHIND COLORBLIND: Despite the evidence to the contrary, Tea Party activists remain aghast at the racism charge and position themselves as the victims of unwarranted accusations. As Coates notes, this "frame-flipping" is a "respectable, more sensible bigotry" that allows practitioners to "change the subject and strawman." A common talking point, salient in the right-wing treatment of race, is a colorblind philosophy that purports race, not racism, is the major problem. References to Martin Luther King, Jr. -- particularly the notion that one should be judged not by the color of his skin but the content of his character -- are favored among colorblind adherents to dismiss the raising of any race issue as divisive. Indeed, Tea Party leaders employed it in their defense against the NAACP in a Politico op-ed this week, stating, "Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. would be proud of this movement. He dreamed of a colorblind society. The tea party is a truly post-racial movement." King's notion of colorblindness, however, was not to say "race shouldn't and doesn't matter" but to convey "what would happen after we as a nation stopped creating disparate outcomes based on race and class." But instead of being upheld as that ideal, the "colorblind racist philosophy" ignores or perpetuates race-based inequality. As blogger Jamelle Bouie points out with the Jim Crow laws and the recent Arizona anti-immigration law, "colorblind mechanisms" are used to craft laws that target minority groups without the explicit mention of race. In other words, if a law doesn't mention race, it isn't racist; if it does, then it is, "even if it's designed to ameliorate racial prejudice." This philosophy also labels anyone who raises race issues as "race baiters" and allows racists "to project their racism onto the minority figures." This is how Tea Party leaders like Mark Williams and David Webb so easily turn the racism charge on the NAACP. Ironically, as is in the case with the Tea Party, by using colorblindness to gloss over charges of racial rhetoric, adherents willingly undermine any effort to achieve the principle they tout.
| BUSINESS -- BOEING LOBBIES LAWMAKERS TO KEEP PURCHASING PLANES THE PENTAGON DOESN'T WANT: Despite strong objections from the Defense Department, the House of Representatives has moved forward to fund a second engine for the F-35 fighter jet. The Pentagon says that the alternative engine is a huge waste of money and has asked Congress to jettison the program, but the House decided to fund it anyway in the 2011 defense authorization bill. The second engine is hardly the only example of wasteful defense spending from Congress: even though the Pentagon hasn't requested any new C-17s -- military transport planes -- over the last four years, "Congress has appropriated $12 billion for 43 of the transport aircraft, including eight in the fiscal 2009 war supplemental spending measure and 10 in the fiscal 2010 Defense appropriations law." As Congressional Quarterly pointed out, Congress' insistence on funding a plane the Pentagon doesn't want is "due in no small part to the lobbying efforts of Boeing Co., which builds the planes in California, Missouri, Georgia, Connecticut and elsewhere." Boeing is also "belatedly lobbying for the purchase of five more C-17s at a cost of about $1.3 billion" for this year. Earlier this year, Secretary of Defense Robert Gates addressed the lobby's influence, saying he's "fully aware of the political pressure to continue building the C-17" while announcing he would "strongly recommend that the president veto any legislation that sustains the unnecessary continuation." As Pentagon officials told a Senate subcommittee this week, "it is not in the national interest to continue adding more C-17s. In our view, the production line should begin shutting down." As the Wonk Room's Pat Garofalo points out, "This isn't just about the upfront cost of purchasing more planes, which is considerable. It's about then paying to maintain the planes for years. The Pentagon actually spends $1 billion per year to maintain the 43 C-17s that it didn't request, but received anyway." President Obama has called the continued purchase of C-17s "waste, pure and simple." |
The Senate Foreign Relations Committee will hold a hearing to discuss BP's role in securing the release of the Libyan terrorist Abdel Basset Ali al-Megrahi, who was convicted for his role in the 1988 airliner bombing over Lockerbie, Scotland. Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) said BP should freeze its operations in Libya because it "should not be allowed to profit on this deal at the expense of the victims of terrorism."
Transocean has already spent $110,000 on a lobbying firm it hired after its Deepwater Horizon rig exploded, tapping "veteran Congressional denizens" to influence Congress on "energy legislation, mobile drilling units and offshore drilling." "Unlike BP, Transocean did not have a major lobbying presence in Washington, D.C., prior to the spill."
Yesterday, the U.S. Army "reported a record number of suicides in a single month among active duty, Guard and Reserve troops, despite an aggressive program of counseling, training and education aimed at suicide prevention." In June, there were 32 soldiers who are believed to have committed suicide, and suicides "for the first half of the year are up 12 percent over 2009."
Judge Jay Bybee, who approved detainee torture under President Bush, told the House Judiciary Committee that "the Central Intelligence Agency never sought approval for some practices detainees later said had been used on them, including dousing them with cold water to keep them awake." "I have regrets because of the notoriety that this has brought me," Bybee said when asked if there was anything he regretted.
"Goldman Sachs has agreed to pay $550 million to settle federal claims that it misled investors in a subprime mortgage product as the housing market began to collapse." The settlement with the SEC "would rank among the largest in the 76-year history" of the agency, but "represent[s] only a small financial dent for Goldman, which reported $13.39 billion in profit last year."
The Senate yesterday passed a sweeping overhaul of the financial industry's regulatory structure, setting the bill up for the President's signature next week. The bill subjects more financial companies to government oversight, "regulates many derivatives contracts, and creates a panel to detect risks to the financial system along with a consumer protection regulator."
Sen. Saxby Chambliss (R-GA) has joined the chorus of Republicans already calling for repeal of the recently-passed financial overhaul bill. "Oh, I'd love for it to be repealed," said Chambliss, the ranking Republican on the Agriculture Committee, which played a key role in writing the bill.
According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, March, April, May, and June set high temperature records, "making 2010 the warmest year worldwide since record-keeping began in 1880." "It's part of an overall trend," said the NOAA's Jay Lawrimore. "Global temperatures…have been rising for the last 100-plus years. Much of the increase is due to increases in greenhouse gases," he said.
Two suicide bombings struck the southeastern Iranian city of Zahedan yesterday, killing 26 injuring at least 300 outside a mosque. The first bomb went off "during Thursday evening prayers," and "[m]inutes later, after a significant crowd of helpers and onlookers had gathered, a second bomber blew himself, spreading greater carnage."
And finally: The Old Spice Guy has some advice for President Obama on how to win back female support.
No comments:
Post a Comment